Ric Osuna went on to claim that the blood on the shoes had resulted from Ronnie and Bobby Kelske cleaning Dawn’s room on the afternoon of November 13th.
To me…that was an absurd claim. Not only was the blood in that picture still wet…but the surroundings in that picture did not match any area of the DeFeo home…nor were any “bloody shoes” ever taken into evidence by the police…
http://www.amityvillefaq.com/truth/Shoes1.htm
Ric Osuna also made a wild claim about a “seventh body” photo that he said he found among the DeFeo crime scene photos.
I think it’s certainly possible that photos from a different crime scene had become mixed-in with the DeFeo crime scene photos…especially after so many years had passed.
A few months ago…our very own Astonio discovered the very possible identity of Ric Osuna’s “seventh body”…
https://www.amityvillefaq.com/truthboar ... f=9&t=6765
...and now I’m wondering…could the “bloody shoes” photo have originated from the same crime scene?
Not only did the murder of Karen Marie DeGennaro happen in the same county as the DeFeo murders…but she was murdered less than a week after Ronnie killed his family.
And if the photos were ever organized by last name…it would have been just about as close as it gets…
DeFeo
DeGennaro
Karen was stabbed…as well as her brother Anthony. Her killer, Vito Coscia, then hid the knife under the living room sofa before going into the bathroom to wash his hands…

…here’s the “bloody shoes” photo…

